About Us

Protecting families. Securing futures.

At Family First Insurance Group, we’re more than just insurance; we’re a testament to the power of family values, community, and the promise of a secure future. Founded on the values of trust, integrity, and community, our journey began with a simple desire—to start a family business that would stand the test of time, serving generations to come, while providing back to our community here in Ohio.

“Protecting families. Securing futures.” This is more than just a slogan—it’s our guiding principle. We take pride in being the safeguard you can rely on, ensuring that your family’s future is secure, no matter what life throws your way. We are not just an insurance agency; we are your partners in protecting what matters most.

We’re local individuals who are always willing to help because we genuinely care. When you choose us, you’re not just choosing an insurance provider; you’re choosing family.

 New addition to the family! Sleep like a baby knowing you’re fully covered!
We are proud to partner with Main Street Insurance Group, who offers 20+ years of serving the community for insurance needs.

Mike O'Rourke, President and Owner of Family First Insurance Group, Inc.

Mike O’Rourke, our esteemed President and Owner, brings a wealth of experience with over 35 years in the insurance industry, including roles as a Regional Sales Manager, claims handling expert, and commercial insurance specialist. Holding prestigious certifications such as CIC and AIC, Mike is licensed in both Property and Casualty Insurance and Life & Health Insurance. Beyond his professional life, he’s deeply rooted in Central Ohio for four decades, emphasizing the importance of family and community. In his leisure time, Mike enjoys exploring new places, cheering for his favorite sports teams (Go Steelers! Go Phillies!), and creating cherished memories with his wife, daughters, beloved grandchildren, and dog Bodhi.

Nick Climer, Partner Agent at Family First Insurance Group, Inc.

Nick Climer, our dedicated Partner Agent, graduated in 2019 from the University of Toledo, boasting a double major in Professional Sales and Marketing. While relatively new to the insurance industry, Nick leverages his prior experience in sales and management, honed over 2 years as a sales territory manager and 2.5 years in inside sales and management roles. He’s a licensed Property and Casualty Insurance agent, and his passion for family, community, and Ohio football makes him an invaluable asset to our team at Family First Insurance Group, Inc.   Whether it’s providing insurance solutions or sharing the excitement for the Buckeyes or the Bengals, Nick is here to support you.  Outside of work, you can find Nick enjoying his time with his wife, Holly, and son, Rhys.

Ready to join our family?

Join our growing family today and experience the difference that true community-based, family-focused insurance can make. Together, we’ll protect your family, secure your future, and build a better tomorrow.